M&M Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches

The creamiest homemade ice cream, made with just four ingredients and no ice cream maker required, is sandwiched between two soft ‘n chewy M&M cookies to make the ultimate summer treat. 

M&M ice cream cookie sandwiches

Whenever I make ice cream sandwiches with homemade cookies, I like to make the cookies a day or two ahead of time to save time on ice cream sandwich day (can we make that a thing?). This way the cookies are ready to go and the dirty dishes are long gone. Hopefully.

This is the easiest ice cream in the entire world. There is no churning. There is no ice cream maker. Four ingredients. All the flavor! One of my favorite parts to this homemade ice cream is that it is so soft and creamy. PLUS. You can use this base ice cream recipe for a variety of homemade ice creams. Just add different add-ins and toppings.

2 images of ingredients for vanilla ice cream and vanilla ice cream in a stand mixer bowl with a whisk attachment

Heavy cream, heavy whipping cream, or double cream can all be used here. The only difference between them all is their milk fat percentage, but any of them make an extraordinary base for this easy homemade ice cream. The key to the mix? The sweetened condensed milk. This thick milk sweetens the ice cream while giving it that rich, creamy texture.

Also in the no-churn ice cream: vanilla extract. This gives the ice cream a little flavor. The three are beaten together until thick and smooth.

Next, add some M&Ms. Be careful folding these in as they can bleed a little color.

vanilla ice cream in a metal bowl with M&Ms and a spatula

Now, taste it. Isn’t that amazing?

M&M ice cream in a metal bowl with a spatula

Pour this homemade ice cream mixture into a plastic container or bowl, cover, and pop in the freezer. Congratulations you now have homemade M&M ice cream.

M&M ice cream cookie sandwiches on a white plate

BOOM. The ultimate summer treat.

Print
clock clock icon cutlery cutlery icon flag flag icon folder folder icon instagram instagram icon pinterest pinterest icon facebook facebook icon print print icon squares squares icon heart heart icon heart solid heart solid icon
M&M ice cream cookie sandwiches on a white plate

M&M Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches

  • Author: Sally
  • Prep Time: 3 hours
  • Cook Time: 10 minutes
  • Total Time: 1 day
  • Yield: 12-15 ice cream sandwiches
  • Category: Frozen Dessert
  • Method: Baking
  • Cuisine: American

Description

The creamiest homemade ice cream, made with just four ingredients and no ice cream maker required, is sandwiched between two soft ‘n chewy M&M®cookies to make the ultimate summer treat.


Ingredients

Ice Cream

  • 2 cups (16 ounces, 480ml) heavy cream
  • 14 ounces (1 can; 396g) sweetened condensed milk
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
  • 1 cup (200g) mini or regular size M&M®s

Cookies


Instructions

  1. Make the ice cream: Using a hand mixer or a stand mixer fitted with whisk attachment, beat the heavy cream, sweetened condensed milk, and vanilla together on high speed until thick and smooth, about 4-5 minutes. Carefully fold in the M&M’s. The M&M’s can bleed their color, so be careful when adding them. Spoon/pour the ice cream mixture into a freezer-safe container or bowl. Cover tightly and freeze overnight. Ice cream can be stored in the freezer for up to 2 weeks.
  2. Make the cookies according to the recipe’s directions. Cool completely.
  3. Assemble the sandwiches: Take a large scoop of ice cream and sandwich it between two cookies. Feel free to roll the sides in crushed M&Ms, chocolate chips, or sprinkles. Freeze the sandwiches until ready to eat. See my tip below this recipe.

Notes

  1. Make Ahead & Freezing Instructions: The baked cookies and prepared ice cream can both be prepared in advance. The ice cream needs to freeze overnight before using, but is tasty for up to 2 weeks in the freezer. The baked cookies stay fresh covered at room temperature for up to 1 week.
  2. No-churn ice cream method from Martha Stewart

Keywords: ice cream cookie sandwiches, M&M cookie ice cream sandwiches

You can prepare these cookie sandwiches ahead of time. Simply prepare the cookies and ice cream, assemble the sandwiches, wrap each tightly in plastic wrap and freeze. Perfect straight from the freezer for a cool treat.

M&M ice cream cookie sandwiches wrapped in plastic wrap

31 Comments

  1. Hi, Sally! Happy Memorial Day weekend! I was wondering if I can freeze the dough for a long time, at least a month? I don’t want to bake a lot of cookies, but I want to have some dough whenever I want cookies. Thanks!

    1. Absolutely! I recommend freezing the cookie dough balls. So, chill the cookie dough as directed, then roll into balls and freeze them. See my make ahead tip in the recipe.

  2. OMG Sally, I just made a batch of the cookies and I can hands down say they are the BEST cookies I have ever made!  I always had trouble with my cookies sinking and getting flat after they came out of the oven but these were perfection.  Thank you SO much for all of your amazing recipes! <3 

  3. Of course I had to try this right away! The whole family loved the ice cream – 3 young kids and 2 older ones (Mom and Dad!). I made hubby’s favourite cookies to go with it – your dark chocolate minus the caramel as I did not have any but chocolate chips worked in a pinch. Delicious!

  4. Sally, I made these for a Memorial Day cookout and they were a HUGE hit! Thank you so much for sharing this recipe!

  5. Hi Sally,

    I made these cookies today & they were delicious & my family loved them. However, I was so disappointed because they turned out very flat. They weren’t fluffy at all like yours. I can’t figure out what I did wrong. I even refrigerated them overnight hoping they wouldn’t spread so much. Thoughts?

    1. Lisa, this is an easy problem to fix. Were you sure to chill the dough? That step is imperative to the cookie’s appearance and texture. Try adding another 3 Tbsp of flour to the cookie dough- this will help bulk it up.

  6. Randi Sellinger says:

    these were unbelievable

  7. Hi Sally! For the ice cream could I replace Heavy Cream with Whipping Cream? Thanks!

  8. These look great! I am going to make the ice cream (with oreos)  sandwiches for my son’s birthday. He would like a traditional soft chocolate cookie. Can I replace some of the flour with cocoa? Or add an egg yolk and change the brown to white sugar ratio in a chocolate cookie recipe to make them softer? Thanks! 

      1. Thanks for the recipes! The ice cream sandwiches were a hit! And the ice cream was so easy! I am living overseas so using an ice cream freezer is currently not an option. Thanks!

  9. Have you ever tried the icecream recipe to make an icecream cake?  I’m making an icecream cake for my friend’s birthday, so I was thinking just to pour the icecream mixture into a springform pan!  Any thoughts?

    1. I haven’t! This ice cream might be a little too soft to make an ice cream cake, though.

  10. Hi Sally, 

    One question.  Do I need to chill the heavy cream first before mixing it with the condensed milk?
    Have just finished making the cookie dough, it’s chilling in the fridge right now. My hubs requested these cookies for his birthday  (which is in 2 days time!). *inrushingmode

    Thanks!
    Ps: Your recipes and photos are awesome!!

    1. Doesn’t matter if the cream is cold or not. Have fun making and enjoying these!

  11. Hi Sally – made these this weekend and my cookies came out completely flat (most of my chocolate chip cookies come out flat).  All of the ingredients were fresh. Any ideas of what I may have done wrong?

    1. The flour– are you using all-purpose flour? And the butter– is it softened but still slightly firm? Or melted at all? Be careful with the butter, you don’t want it too greasy or melted down in the slightest. Try adding 3 more Tbsp of flour. This will help soak up some moisture and help them keep their shape. Also, do not skip chilling the dough. The longer the better.

  12. Hi Sally! Is it possible to make these into bars? If yes, will the baking time change? Thank you so much in advance!!!

    1. Like ice cream cookie bars? Sounds good! The bake time will be longer. I would use a 9×9 inch square baking pan.

  13. I made these for a summer BBQ with friends.  Everyone raved about them!  The homemade ice cream is super delicious, and we loved the cookies so much, I’ve made them several times since then. We love them stored in the frig.  Thank you for the recipe!

  14. OMG! So good! I love the original but the kids wanted chocolate so I added 1 cup chocolate syrup and it was awesome! Best chocolate ice cream ever!

  15. Hi Sally! The ice cream was sooo good, but how do you prevent so much of the M&Ms from bleeding? It looked a little unappetizing after it was frozen. Also the M&Ms didn’t mix very well-they sort of sank to the bottom. Any tips with this?

    1. Hi Debbie! I wish I had a solution other than stirring slowly and as little as possible. The M&Ms bleeding their color happens to me too!

    2. Hi Debbie,
      I have made this ice cream tons of times. My solution is to pre-freeze the vanilla base before adding the M&M’s. After roughly 1.5 hours, when my cream base has the consistency of soft serve, I fold in the M&Ms. They still bleed but they don’t sink.

  16. Hello Sally!

    I am planning to make your Rainbow M&M Cookies and stumbled on to this delectable looking M&M Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches version… my mouth is watering already!
    I noticed one slight difference between the two cookie recipes in that this one calls for 1tsp Cornstarch and the other one does not. Is the cornstarch specific and necessary the ice cream sandwich version and why?
    Thanks again for all of your wonderful recipe sharing! 🙂

    1. Hi Nicole! So I started adding cornstarch to the cookies because it adds a little extra softness, chew, and thickness. I love it in cookie recipes! It’s optional, but I make a lot of my “chocolate chip” style cookies with it these days.

  17. I made these cookies and although they were delicious, I’m not sure why they’re not as thick as the ones in your pictures. My oven temperature is right, I’ve checked it with an oven thermometer. My butter was room temperature as well as my egg, and my dry were measured with a scale. What do you think could be the issue? They chilled for 3 hours.

    1. Hi Leslie, I’m glad to help. Without knowing exactly what went wrong, I suggest these 10 Guaranteed Tips to Prevent Cookies from Spreading if you’re interested to review. My go-to trick is adding 2-3 extra Tablespoons of flour which will help soak up more butter and reduce spread.

  18. Love this recipe!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

With kitchen-tested quality recipes and step-by-step tutorials, my goal is to give you the confidence to bake and cook from scratch.

Sally's signature

Recipes You’ll Love

Archives

Categories

Join the community on the 1st of every month as we tackle a new challenge recipe. Review Sally's Baking Challenge FAQ page if you have any questions.

View More

A tradition since 2013, every December we countdown to Christmas with 10 new cookie recipes in a row!

View More

The first week of every November is all about Thanksgiving Pies.

View More

My Cookbooks

Sally's Cookbooks

About Sally

Welcome to my Kitchen!

I’m Sally, a cookbook author, photographer, and blogger. My goal is to give you the confidence and knowledge to cook and bake from scratch while providing quality recipes and plenty of pictures. Grab a cookie, take a seat, and have fun exploring! more about Sally

×
Skip to toolbar