Savor the best part of the day with ultra comforting eggs benedict. Learn how to poach eggs and create this restaurant quality meal at home!
It’s Friiiiiday. Let’s talk about weekend breakfasts for a sec. Are you a savory breakfast person or a sweet breakfast person? Veggie omelets with crispy hash browns or a stack of buttermilk pancakes? Cheesy quiche or cinnamon swirl crumb cake?
Or are you a “nothing because I’m still half asleep” person? That would be my husband. I don’t get it. I’m ravenous in the morning.
Back to what I was saying. I’m most definitely a sweets person… SURPRISE surprise. However, there is one exception. I would absolutely choose a muffin over a hard boiled egg any day, but when eggs benedict are involved… that. Always that.
Luxurious eggs benedict is one of life’s simple pleasures. It’s just guaranteed to make your mornings spectacular. I never usually take the time to prepare this brunch standard at home, especially since a bakery style muffin requires less thought and, well, chocolate.
But when you actually spend time in the kitchen making the silky hollandaise from scratch or perfectly poaching the eggs to get that magnificent runny egg yolk, you may just appreciate this glorious breakfast and the entire experience of preparing it… even more.
I’ve had eggs benedict many ways while out to brunch with friends. My favorite? Eggs benedict topped with jumbo lump Maryland crab and Old Bay – served in Baltimore, of course. Lifechanging. I’ve also had eggs benedict with sliced avocado on top and nearly lost my mind it was so good. And (last one, promise) I also like eggs blackstone – ever try that? It’s the same as eggs benedict but there’s crispy bacon instead of canadian bacon. And there’s a tomato slice, which is the red you see in my eggs benedict today.
I now love preparing eggs benedict with a thick, peppered tomato slice.
Let me walk you through a few things before you begin the recipe.
Homemade hollandaise. This is a recipe I’ve been making for awhile. Melted butter, egg yolks, a touch of lemon juice, salt, and pepper. That’s all. The trick here is to melt the butter first. Do that before anything else. Then, let the butter cool as you poach the eggs. You absolutely do not want your melted butter to be scorching hot because it will cook the egg yolks. Resulting in a chunky, strange, not at all appetizing hollandaise sauce.
Oh, and I make my hollandaise in a blender. I learned this method from talking with a William’s Sonoma employee. Totally normal to somehow get in a conversation about hollandaise while at the mall?! Weird life. Weird life.
Poached eggs. Ok, I began typing this post one morning after having 3 cups of coffee. And the more I worked on it, the longer and more drawn out this poached egg paragraph became. Apparently I’m pretty chatty about eggs. So, I’ll let you poached egg experts skip all that and just make the recipe below. But for anyone learning how to make the perfect poached egg, see my poached egg spiel below the recipe.
Besides homemade hollandaise and poached eggs, you’ll need a toasty english muffin and a thick slice of Canadian bacon. If you care to try my tomato addition, you’ll need 2 tomatoes as well. I like to lightly cook the sliced tomatoes and brown the Canadian bacon before adding to the eggs benedict. A little sprinkle of pepper adds flavor.
Sure this breakfast is incredibly rich, but enjoyed every now and then? Makes it even more special. Treat yourself to a lavish Sunday morning meal. And maybe even eat it in bed. 😉 Enjoy!
Follow me on Instagram and tag #sallysbakingaddiction so I can see all the SBA recipes you make. ♥
Sunday Morning Eggs Benedict
Sunday morning eggs benedict is a tradition for me. Spending time preparing this lavish brunch is almost as enjoyable as that first bite of the poached egg, creamy hollandaise, and crispy Canadian bacon. Read how to poach the perfect egg below my recipe.
- 2 medium tomatoes, cut into 4 slices each (optional)
- 1 teaspoon olive oil
- salt & fresh ground pepper, to taste
- 8 slices Canadian bacon
- 4 English muffins (I like using whole wheat - or try making your own)
- 2 teaspoons distilled white vinegar1
- 8 large eggs1
- 7 Tablespoons unsalted butter
- 3 large egg yolks
- 1 Tablespoon fresh lemon juice
- salt & fresh ground pepper, to taste
- I prefer to begin with the butter used to make the hollandaise sauce. Melt the butter in a small dish over the stove or in the microwave. Set aside to allow it to cool down. You do NOT want scorching hot melted butter - this will cook the egg yolks. So, I always melt it before poaching the eggs and finish the hollandaise right before serving.
- Heat 1 teaspoon olive oil in a skillet over medium heat. Place the tomatoes and Canadian bacon to the skillet, sprinkle the tomatoes with a pinch of salt and pepper. Cook the tomatoes and Canadian bacon on both sides for 2 minutes each. Even though the Canadian bacon is pre-cooked, I like it warm and slightly crisp. Feel free to cook it in the skillet a little longer. The tomatoes only need 2 minutes on each side. Turn off the heat and set the skillet aside.
- Poach the eggs using your preferred method. I poach my eggs using Kevin's method explained (in great!) detail below this recipe. Feel free to use any poached egg tutorial you like. The below method works best for me. Read it through before beginning. In the last step you'll read at the very bottom of this post, I give my tips for cooking 8 poached eggs and having them all be warm for serving.
- Toast the English muffins to your liking. Add two toasted English muffin halves onto 4 plates. Set aside.
- Finish the hollandaise. Place the egg yolks and lemon juice in a blender. Blend on high speed for 30 seconds until combined. Give the melted butter a quick whisk to combine any bits that separated. Working quickly and with the blender running on medium speed, remove lid insert and slowly pour melted butter into blender in a thin stream. Blend until creamy sauce forms. Season to taste with salt and pepper and add a little more fresh lemon juice if you prefer. A dash of hot sauce is also tasty. *If you do not own a blender, you may use a whisk. Make sure you are whisking vigorously.
- Top the English muffin halves with 1 slice Canadian bacon, followed by a tomato slice. Carefully top with poached egg and generously drizzle each with prepared hollandaise sauce. Sprinkle with fresh ground pepper, if desired.
- Enjoy immediately. Recipe may easily be halved to only serve 2 people. Poached eggs are best used the day they're cooked, but they can be kept overnight in the ice bath explained in the last step below.
- See Poached Eggs by Kevin below to learn how I poach eggs - using the vinegar.
Did you make a recipe?
Tag @sallysbakeblog on Instagram and hashtag it #sallysbakingaddiction.
Poached Eggs by Kevin
First, read my instructions before you begin! I actually recommend this with any recipe you follow whether that’s in a cookbook, on a blog, a dessert, dinner, whatever. Knowing the when, why, where, and how before you begin saves you time, a headache, and decreases the likelihood of a mistake.
Poached eggs are easier than you think to master. I know it seems difficult and “why not just make scrambled eggs, they’re easier” but the runny egg yolk (!!!) is the best part. There are so many different tricks and techniques I’ve read about and I’m sure there are more that you will share with me. Feel free! I am absolutely no expert on poaching eggs, but what I’m sharing is just the way I poach eggs. Actually, how Kevin poaches eggs. I learned how to make soft pretzels and how to make poached eggs from him. Total keeper.
As with most cooking and baking, practice makes perfect. It took me a few tries to get the perfect poached egg, so don’t get discouraged. They won’t all be perfect at first.
1) Watch this video from professional chef Jamie Oliver about poaching eggs. It is so helpful and will give you visuals of what you’re doing. Someday, I’ll make a video of this for you. Promise. Kevin used Jamie’s video to teach himself and then to teach me. We prefer the first method Jamie shows. It’s the easiest.
2) Start with the freshest of fresh eggs. Absolutely positively the freshest eggs you can. I try to grab a carton from the very bottom or the very back of the egg selection in the store. They’re always the freshest. Why the freshest eggs? The fresher the egg, the more firm and sturdy the egg white.
3) The pot. Some people prefer wide skillet pans, but I prefer a deep pot. Especially when I’m poaching more than a couple eggs at a time. Fill a pot with 3-4 inches of water. Heat the water on high until it reaches a bare simmer and bubbles start appearing at the bottom of the pan. Just before boiling. If you care to be extra precise, you’re looking for about 190F degrees.
4) At this point, add 2 teaspoons of distilled white vinegar. Jamie says he does not do this because it makes your eggs taste like vinegar, but I do not think the eggs taste like vinegar at all. I also use a very small amount for 8 eggs (if making 4 poached eggs, reduce white vinegar to 1 teaspoon – if making 2 poached eggs, reduce to 1/2 teaspoon.) Some people, like Jamie, are very anti-vinegar, but I find my poached eggs turn out best with this little addition. Especially if (1) your eggs aren’t straight-from-the-chicken fresh and (2) when I’m making more than 1 or 2 poached eggs at a time. The vinegar helps reduce the “feathering” of the egg white when it’s dropped in the water as well as prevents the egg white from sticking to the bottom of the pot.
5) Working with one egg at a time, crack the egg into a small bowl or cup. Place the bowl close to the surface of the hot water and slip the egg into the water. Repeat with 3 more eggs. I only like to poach 4 eggs in the pot at a time. NOTE! Some people swear by the “whirlpool” method. Basically, you create a whirlpool in the center of the barely simmering water and gently drop the egg in the whirlpool. This helps the egg white wrap around the yolk. Jamie shows the whirlpool trick at the 2:00 minute mark of the video. I’ve tried both ways (whirlpool vs no whirlpool) and honestly do not find it necessary. However, try it if you’d like.
6) Turn off the heat and cover the pot. My preferred cook time for poached eggs is between 3:30 – 4 minutes. So, set a timer for 3:30 minutes. If the egg white around the yolk still looks translucent, give it an additional 30 seconds. If you like your eggs more done, cook for 4 – 4:30 minutes. After 4 minutes, the egg whites should be completely cooked with the egg yolks still runny. PLEASE NOTE that the time depends on the size of the eggs, if they were cold or at room temperature to begin with, and/or if you are cooking at high altitude (in which they’d likely need to be cooked a little longer). If you find 3:30-4 minutes is too long for your eggs and the yolks aren’t runny enough, reduce the time by 30 seconds in your next batch.
7) Gently lift the poached eggs out of the pan with a slotted spoon and place on a paper towel lined plate. Sometimes I trim a bit of the excess egg white off around the yolk, though that is not necessary.
8) If you are making 8 poached eggs, like my recipe above, follow the preceding instructions and then: Fill a large bowl halfway with water and add a handful of ice cubes. Poach the eggs as directed, then remove from the pot and slip into the ice water. When all 8 eggs are done, bring a pot of water to a boil, add the eggs and cook for 20 to 30 seconds to warm them up again. The eggs are best used the day they’re cooked, but they can be kept overnight in the ice bath.