This Sally’s Baking Challenge Has Ended

Visit the Sally’s Baking Challenge page for FAQs and all the previous challenge recipes.

May Baking Challenge Results

May 2022 Sally’s Baking Challenge Recipe: Brown Butter Berry Tea Cakes. These little cakelets were a popular recipe in May! Many participants baked them for Mother’s Day and afternoon tea, some for bake sales and bridal showers, or just a special treat after dinner. A lot of readers loved this unique spin on a classic madeleine cookie, something you may not have ever made or tasted before!

Thank you so much for participating! We gathered as many emailed photo entries as we could and included them below.

May Baking Challenge Winner

Challenge winner for May is Rachel who has already been notified.

May 2022 Sally's Baking Challenge winner's brown berry tea cakes photo

Reader Questions and Reviews

  1. Peanut Butter filled brownie cookies were fun to see how the marbling turned out. Espresso powder gave some flavor.

  2. What a great recipe! I accidentally made a double batch. (don’t ask how this happens) I took some to a friend and when I babysat the next day, I had some very picky children declare them delicious and best ever! Thanks for another great one!

  3. The cookies were very rich with the chocolate and peanut butter. Everyone enjoyed them.

  4. Awesome recipie…My Husband rated it a 10/10! So fun to make!

  5. These were very fun to make with my 6 year old. She loved rolling the peanut butter and cookie balls!

  6. My family loved this recipe! They enjoyed the taste of cookies. Thanks Sally for conducting baking challenges so we can improve in baking. I really loved all your recipes.

Leave a Review!

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.