Sprinkled Episode 7: Perfecting Pie Crust

Jump to Recipe

Sally McKenney Sprinkled Episode 7

The key to making great pie is… GREAT PIE CRUST!

Do any of these sound like you?

  • You’re intimidated by pie crust
  • Your pie crust never turns out
  • You don’t have the faintest idea how to make pie crust

Today, in Sprinkled episode 7, I’m spilling ALL the beans for perfecting pie crust and it begins with a solid pie crust recipe. I teach you how to lattice pie crust and create a beautiful design using a leaf cookie cutter. This 15 minute video tutorial is my longest episode yet, but I want to make sure you walk away 100% confident in your pie crust abilities.

Because you can master pie crust on the 1st try!

Lattice pie crust design on sallysbakingaddiction.com

Leaf pie crust design on sallysbakingaddiction.com

Episode 7

Episode 7 recipe: Buttery Flaky Pie Crust and Deep Dish Apple Pie

Do you prefer all butter pie crust? You can use my butter pie crust recipe and apply the same tips shared in the video. Let me know if you find episode 7 helpful!

What is Sprinkled?

View all Sprinkled videos.

Earlier this year, a video production crew filmed me at work in my kitchen. Most of the time was spent filming step-by-step recipe tutorials, but they also filmed me working, writing, photographing, and recipe testing. The series is called Sprinkled. 🙂 For the recipe tutorials, I selected my favorite blog recipes ranging from cookies and cake to brownies and pie.

Coming Next: Episode 8

Get ready for Christmas cookies! Check back in December for the Sprinkled final episode.

Brown butter sugar cookies with extra sprinkles

Sprinkled episodes are featured every month on my blog in partnership with my talented production & multimedia crew, Grateful & Co. Want to stay updated? Subscribe to my blog and each new blog post will be emailed to you on the day it’s published, including when a new Sprinkled episode is live! Sprinkled photos and videos by Grateful & Co 🙂

49 Comments

  1. Hey Sally, this is your best video yet; you seem so comfortable/at ease in front of the camera now! Love the pie decorations…..but truth be told, the lattice scares me. (Says the spatially challenged woman who can’t get her star bread points even.) But there is hope for me; I bought an apple slicer/corer today that has 16 insets- that should help me make even triangles. I’ll let you know if I give the pie a try…..the problem is I’m not allowed into my cousin’s house unless I bring a batch of your brownies. Maybe I can make make the pie dough and fill it with your brownie batter, LOL!!! Hope you and your family have a wonderful Thanksgiving and I can’t wait until cookie week! (My kid’s friends affectionately call me “Cookie Lady.”) So looking forward to adding to my repertoire…….

    1. Thank you so much! It’s SO HARD to be in front of the camera. I don’t know how actors and actresses do it. Talking into a camera feels so unnatural, especially when you’re talking AND doing something at the same time. But pie crust is 2nd nature to me so that must be why this video felt so easy! I appreciate it so much.

      PS: brownie pie in pie crust is definitely a thing HAHA! Hope your Thanksgiving holiday is wonderful too. Let me know how the pie turns out.

  2. I loved watching you make pie crust & pie! I made your pie crust and apple pie once and they are fabulous! Looking forward to the next episode! Love cookies!

  3. I dread making a pie crust. I hope to make one as soon as I watch the video and will comment on how it turns out. I wish you and your family a Happy Thanksgiving.

  4. Happy Thanksgiving Sally,
    Another wonderful episode! I really appreciated the in-depth look at pie crust making. I haven’t used shortening in my pie crust since my grandmother was alive. Time to crack out the Crisco! You truly are a joy to watch. Can’t wait for Episode 8.

  5. Ahh! I have been waiting for another Sprinkled episode. So excited for this one! Kinda sad that episode 8 is the last one . But anyways, great episode! Love them all.

  6. Sally, you gave me the confidence to try pie crust again! I’ve done it in the past and never been happy with the results. I’ve made two pies in the last month using your crust recipe and the finished products were delicious! I’m making another one this weekend for one more practice run before Thanksgiving and I expect it will be just as yummy. Thank you for all of your helpful tips and guidance.

  7. Great video, Sally! It’s always so helpful to watch you making something, because then when I’m doing it I know exactly how something should look, every step of the way.
    Also, good for you, for getting up in front of a camera to do this for us! You look great, and I’d never guess that you are the least bit uncomfortable. Pie dough is deployed one week early for turkey day! (for experimentation purposes exclusively. I am not an impatient person 🙂

  8. Thank you for the pep talk and the clearcut video! I’m going to stop cheating with frozen commercial pie crusts and make my very first piecrust.

  9. Some really great tips particularly learning how the dough feels for a good crust.
    I’m probably old enough to be your mother . When I learned to make pie crusts we didn’t have a pastry cutter so we used two dinner knives making crisscross cuts thru the flour shortening mixture. Came in handy during my poor college days.

  10. Thanks for such a great video Sally! Perfect timing, of course.
    Was wondering if you have any tips on using foil pie dishes. I know glass is preferred, but I’m making some pies for friends to take to their family dinners on Thanksgiving, and don’t want to give them the responsibility of returning my glass pie dish.
    Would you have to grease a foil pan? Would you double up so it cooks more evenly? Or would you avoid it all together?
    Have a wonderful Thanksgiving!
    -Shawn

  11. Hi Sally! I was wondering what you think about re-rolling the pie crust scraps, after cutting shapes etc, in order to cut more! Thanks!

  12. Hi Sally, in Portugal we don’t have shortning,what can i use instead,lard will it do the trick,thank you for your kindness

  13. I won 1st place and best of division this year at the Gold Country Fair with Sally’s pie crust recipe. I make pie all the time. I love baking pies. Truth be told: you have to be bigger than your pie dough! It knows when you make it if your being cowardly. Take charge!

  14. Once again a wonderful video. It is difficult to be so relaxed in front of a camera and you do an excellent job! I will be making your all butter crust today for my pumpkin pie. I brought back a can of pumpkin from the US and pumpkin pie will be one of the desserts for tomorrow’s expat Thanksgiving. I would make your chocolate coconut tart as well, but there are people coming with both coconut and almond allergies so I had to come up with another chocolate tart recipe. Thanks for the videos and the wonderful recipes.

  15. I think you are so adorable, Sally! I love that you don an apron…and cute ones at that! I’ve been enjoying your videos but this pie crust video takes the cake. I’ve always struggled with pie crusts and it was very humbling and frustrating at the same time when my daughter made a perfect pie crust the first time she tried. I’ m going to try your recipe and I’ll show her who makes the best pie crust…lol! She reads your blog as well so here’s hoping she misses this one.

    1. Thank you so much Judy!!! Here’s hoping your next pie crust adventure ends with success. I’m positive it will. Let me know how it goes!

  16. Love your pie dough! It is my go to recipe now, has been since I tried it a few years ago.
    I take the extra dough pieces and dip them in cinnamon sugar and fry them. Kids love it!

  17. I loved this episode (and all the previous ones), and am anxiously looking forward to Cookiepalooza! I was just wondering, would you consider doing a holiday gift guide, or a list of your favorite baking tools/products? I know you have a few older lists on your site, but I think you have been using different baking pans/cookie sheets since you wrote them, and I would love to know your recommendations as I shop for the bakers in my family this Christmas… and for myself too!

  18. Hi, I am confused as in the video you used Crisco and butter but when I link to the recipe it is for an all-butter pie crust. Do you prefer one over the other?

  19. Help! I tried making your pie crust recipe but it fell apart when I started rolling it.I thought I followed your instructions but maybe I did something wrong? I’ve made my mother’s recipe for years and never had any problems but I wanted to try a different recipe. Thanks

    1. Hi Nancy! It sounds like the dough wasn’t moist enough. Use moistened fingers to work ice water back into the dough until it’s easy to roll out again.

  20. I finally succeeded at making a homemade pie crust and it is all because of this tutorial! The last time I failed at making pie crust my father seriously asked me if I used plastic to make the crust, it was so tough you could hardly cut it! But after watching your video I felt confident I have what it takes to make pie crust. I just focused on your advice to be gentle on the dough. Even though I second guessed everything I did and was sure that I was messing it up, it came out flaky and tender and delicious. It wasn’t pretty like yours, but that will come later. I’m celebrating one win at a time.

  21. Hi Sally.
    I enjoyed watching your pie crust sprinkled video episode . I do not know how to make a pie at all
    Let alone a pie crust. This was very informative, like all your sprinkled video episodes you do a very good job with the instructions you give.
    I like the interview segments of the videos as well.
    I will be watching your final episode of this series.

    1. Thank you so much for watching these episodes, Heather! I’m really happy readers have been finding them helpful, especially for “tricky” recipes like homemade pie crust.

  22. Your video removed many confusion I’m preparing this recipe. I have tried to make Pie Crust many time reading different blogs but it was never perfect. Some time it became to hard some time soft.
    So, I start cooking step by step by your video and this time it’s perfect. Keep posting such wonderful videos.

  23. I’v been trying to get the perfect pie crust right for the last year and a half and this tutorial helped me finally nail it! I’ve always had a crust that’s just a TINY bit too dry, and seeing how yours came together really helped me visualize how it should look! So, I added 1-2 extra tablespoons of water and my dough was perfect! Thanks Sally!

  24. Sally — Thank you for this tutorial. I have been trying to mast pie crusts for some 30+ years. My mom was a fantastic baker, so I’m trying to do her proud; however, every time I try, my crust edges break as I’m rolling out the dough. I’ve tried many different recipes, even rolling out the dough without chilling it. No luck. Any suggestions? Could it be the dough was too dry, even though it came together? I’m going home after work today and trying your recipe. Wish me luck!

    1. Hi Joanne! If your pie dough is cracking around the edges, it is too dry. Most pie dough recipes don’t call for enough water. I add up to 2/3 cup of ice water to my pie dough, especially during the dry winter months! To fix it, moisten your fingertips with water and work the moisture into the cracked dough.

  25. This pie looks so delicious! I have never made an apple pie before, but this Sprinkled episode inspired me to try. Thanks for the wonderful instructions and ideas!

  26. Hi Sally I am watching this pie dough sprinkled episode again and I am wondering where did you get the cute rubber spatulas you have in your kitchen? I like the green that says I never met a cookie I didn’t like, the what one with the hearts on it are really cute and the red one that read keep calm and bake on. Thank lease let me know where you bought these. And another question if I want to make a savory turnover using your buttery flaky pie crust recipe ( I found such a recipe on Pinterest
    For mushroom turnovers) how much do I reduce the salt in this pie crust recipe? So it won’t overpower the mushrooms cheese, and spices I will be adding . PLease let me know about this as well. I have this recipe of yours written down with all of the notes you provided as well. I really want my first time at making homemade pie a success
    And each time I will be making homemade pie dough for different things a success every Time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

With kitchen-tested quality recipes and step-by-step tutorials, my goal is to give you the confidence to bake and cook from scratch.

Recipes You’ll Love

Archives

Categories

Sally's Baking Challenge

Join the community on the 1st of every month as we tackle a new challenge recipe.

View More

Sally's Cookie Palooza

A tradition since 2013, every December we countdown to Christmas with 10 new cookie recipes in a row!

View More

Sally's Pie Week

The first week of every November is all about Thanksgiving Pies.

View More

My Cookbooks

About Sally

Welcome to my Kitchen!

I’m Sally, a cookbook author, photographer, and blogger. My goal is to give you the confidence and knowledge to cook and bake from scratch while providing quality recipes and plenty of pictures. Grab a cookie, take a seat, and have fun exploring! more about Sally

×